Option payoffs are lopsided: a bought option can multiply its premium or lose all of it, and the price usually has to move a long way just to break even.
12 min read · Level 5
The percentage returns quoted in options are real and I think they are the most misleading numbers in retail investing, because they describe the premium rather than the decision. A 400% gain on 300 is 1,200. A strategy that produces a few of those among many total losses can lose money steadily while generating a stream of screenshots that suggest the opposite. The honest unit of measurement is the running total of all trades.
Take a share at 100. You buy one call, strike 105, premium 3, covering 100 shares, for 300. At expiry:
Share price Option value Profit or loss On 300 paid 95 0 -300 -100% 105 0 -300 -100% 108 300 0 0% 120 1,500 +1,200 +400%
The break-even is the strike plus the premium: 105 + 3 = 108. The share must rise 8% just to get your money back, and anything at or below 105 loses everything.
Compare buying 100 shares for 10,000: at 120 you gain 2,000 (+20%); at 95 you lose 500 (-5%). The option gives a bigger percentage when right and a total loss when mildly wrong.
Futures work through margin. A contract worth 50,000 might require 5,000 of margin. A 6% fall in price costs 3,000, which is 60% of the margin. A 10% fall costs 5,000, the whole margin, and you will be asked to add money or have the position closed.
Option sellers earn the premium when options expire worthless, which is often. The cost is occasional large losses when the price moves sharply against them.
Because the payoff shape drives behaviour. Winning trades can show 300% or 400%, which is memorable and widely shared. The many small total losses are quieter. An investor who remembers the wins may believe options are more profitable than their own records show.
It also shows why option selling looks attractive: frequent small gains. The pattern resembles picking up coins in front of a steamroller - steady until the rare day it is not.
And margin means futures losses arrive as demands for cash, not just as falling numbers on a screen.
This is educational information, not investment, securities or financial advice. Rules differ by country and change — get advice from a qualified professional in your jurisdiction before acting.
Educational, not personalised financial advice. Nothing in the Investor Academy is a recommendation to buy, sell or hold anything — what is right for you depends on your own circumstances and the rules where you live.
Sources: U.S. SEC - Investor.gov; FINRA - Investor Insights; U.S. CFTC - Commodity Futures Trading Commission
Ten trades, same approach, the same 300 each.
Outcome Trades Result each Total Expired worthless 7 -300 -2,100 Roughly break-even 2 0 0 Share rose to 120 1 +1,200 +1,200 Total spent: 3,000 -900
One trade showed +400%, which is what the investor talks about. Across ten trades they lost 900, or 30% of what they put in. The pattern depends entirely on the assumed outcomes, but it shows why a single large win says little about whether a strategy makes money.
Judging an options approach by its best trade. The relevant number is total profit or loss across every trade, including all the premiums that expired worthless.
For a call, strike plus premium; for a put, strike minus premium. Ask how far and how fast the price must move to reach it.
Record premium paid or received and the final result for each position, then total them.
Divide margin by contract value. A 10% margin means a 10% adverse move loses all of it.
Before placing any option or futures trade, and when reviewing whether a derivatives strategy has actually worked.
Do not use the example outcomes as expected probabilities. Real results depend on prices, volatility and time, and are frequently worse for short-term retail trading.
Academic studies and regulator commentary on retail options trading have reported that individual traders as a group lost money on options in recent periods, with losses concentrated in short-dated contracts and high-volatility names, once bid-ask spreads and premiums were accounted for.
The shorter the time to expiry, the less room there is to be right before the contract ends.
Create a free account to read the rest and apply it to your own investing.