Thinking method · Galef, The Scout Mindset
The scout question
A check on whether you are trying to see clearly or trying to win. Whenever you notice yourself researching a conclusion you already hold.
Free — no account needed to read
A check on whether you are trying to see clearly or trying to win.
The steps
- Notice a belief you are defending.
- Ask: would I accept this same evidence if it pointed the other way?
- Ask: am I looking for whether this is true, or for reasons it is true?
- Ask: what would I have to see to change my mind? Write it down specifically.
- If nothing would, say so plainly — that is a finding about the belief, not a failure.
When to use it
Whenever you notice yourself researching a conclusion you already hold.
What it will not do
Knowing the question does not stop you doing it. Writing the answer down is what helps.
Where it comes from: Galef, The Scout Mindset. Described in our own words.
The module it belongs to
- Reflective Thinking — Examine your own reasoning